New York has more Shopify agencies than any other US city, and most “best of” lists are written by one of them. This one is too: we are Hyuman, a New York Shopify Plus agency, and we are on it. So instead of a ranking, here is a shortlist grouped by the kind of brand each agency fits best, based on what each one publishes about itself and its Shopify partner listing. Check every claim directly before you sign.

01 — How to Read This

Pick by Fit, Not by Rank

The right Shopify Plus agency depends on three things: your budget, your category, and how complex your operations are. A $30,000 DTC rebuild and a $300,000 B2B replatform from Salesforce Commerce Cloud need very different partners. Start there, then use the list below to find agencies that do your kind of work every week.


02 — CPG

Barrel: Consumer Packaged Goods

Barrel was founded in New York in 2006 and has been a Shopify Plus partner since 2017. It describes itself as a commerce agency for CPG brands, covering Shopify DTC, POS, B2B and marketplaces. Publicly named clients include McCormick, Hu and Sweet Loren’s.

Best fit: established food, beverage and household brands that sell across DTC, retail and Amazon.

03 — B2B

BlueSwitch: B2B and Complex Catalogs

BlueSwitch is based in Lower Manhattan and has been a Shopify partner since 2013; Shopify’s partner directory lists it as a Platinum partner. It runs a separate B2B practice, B2 by BlueSwitch, focused on company accounts, custom price lists and bulk ordering.

Best fit: manufacturers and distributors moving wholesale onto Shopify Plus. Expect enterprise budgets.

04 — Fashion

Avex: Fashion, Beauty and Lifestyle

Avex presents itself as a New York Shopify Platinum partner, with a portfolio centered on fashion, beauty and lifestyle brands. Its partner listings name brands such as Kith and KHAITE.

Best fit: design-led fashion and beauty brands where the storefront is part of the brand.

05 — Enterprise

Domaine: Enterprise Replatforming

Domaine is a large Shopify Plus agency with a New York headquarters, positioned for enterprise brands moving from Salesforce Commerce Cloud, Adobe Commerce or custom platforms.

Best fit: large retailers with complex integrations (ERP, OMS, PIM) and a six-figure budget.

06 — CRO

Blackbelt Commerce: Conversion-Focused Builds

Blackbelt Commerce is a Shopify Plus partner with a Manhattan office that leads with conversion rate optimization and ongoing growth retainers.

Best fit: brands already on Shopify that want continuous testing and optimization more than a full rebuild.

07 — Fixed Price

Hyuman: Fixed-Price Custom Stores

That is us. Hyuman is a Shopify Plus and Webflow agency serving New York and US brands. We build custom Shopify and Shopify Plus stores, including headless storefronts on Hydrogen and Next.js, at one fixed price and launch date agreed before work starts. Projects start at $10,000, most custom stores land between $15,000 and $50,000, and most launch in 6–10 weeks.

Clients include UCAN, Alkamind and Climatic, and we hold a 5.0 rating across 9 verified reviews on Clutch.

Best fit: growing DTC brands that want senior design and engineering without enterprise overhead. See how we work as a Shopify Plus agency.


08 — Shortlisting

Questions to Ask Every Agency

  • Can you show three live Shopify stores in our category, launched in the last two years?
  • Is the price fixed, or billed hourly? What happens if the scope changes?
  • Who will actually design and build our store, and are they in-house or contractors?
  • How do you handle migration: products, customers, orders, URLs and redirects?
  • What does support look like after launch, and what does it cost?
  • Can we speak to two past clients?

09 — Budget

What NYC Shopify Plus Agencies Cost

Smaller New York studios typically quote from about $10,000 for a theme-based refresh and $15,000–$50,000 for a custom store. Large Platinum agencies usually start around $50,000 and go well past $250,000 for enterprise replatforming. For the full breakdown, read what a custom Shopify store costs in 2026, and for help comparing proposals, see how to choose a Shopify agency.

Want a second opinion on your shortlist? book a free 30-minute call and we will tell you honestly whether we are the right fit.