Choosing a Shopify agency is one of the bigger bets a DTC brand makes. Get it right and you have a partner who ships fast and grows revenue. Get it wrong and you lose a quarter, a budget and sometimes your SEO. These are the questions we would ask if we were on your side of the table.

01 — Proof

Questions About Their Track Record

  • Can I see live stores you built, not just mockups? Visit them on your phone and check speed and checkout.
  • Have you built for brands like mine? Subscriptions, bundles, supplements and multi-market stores each have their own pitfalls.
  • Can I read verified reviews? Clutch reviews are verified by a third party; testimonials on a website are not.
  • Can I talk to a past client? A good agency will happily connect you.

02 — Process

Questions About How They Work

  • Who will actually build my store? Find out if the work is done in-house or outsourced, and who your day-to-day contact is.
  • Is pricing fixed-scope or hourly? Fixed-scope gives you one number and puts the risk of overruns on the agency.
  • What does your timeline look like, week by week? A clear plan names a launch date and the milestones before it.
  • How do you handle SEO during a redesign or migration? The answer should include a full redirect map and post-launch monitoring.

03 — After Launch

Questions About What Happens After Go-Live

  • What support is included after launch? We include 15 days of free post-launch support on every project; ask what yours includes.
  • Will my team be able to edit the store without a developer? Sections, metafields and a clear handover matter more than any single feature.

04 — Red Flags

Warning Signs to Watch For

Be careful if an agency can’t show live work, quotes before understanding your scope, insists on proprietary apps that lock you in, or can’t explain how they will protect your search rankings. A proposal with no “out of scope” section is another warning sign: it usually means the arguments come later.


05 — Shopify vs Plus

Do You Need a Shopify Plus Agency Specifically?

Not always. Shopify Plus makes sense for high-volume brands, or if you need B2B, expansion stores for other markets or deeper checkout customization. Most growing brands start on a standard plan. A good agency will tell you honestly which one you need, and build so you can upgrade later without a rebuild.

06 — Our Answers

How Hyuman Answers These Questions

We are a New York-based Shopify Plus agency that works with brands across the US. Our work includes UCAN, Alkamind, Boulder Bio, Climatic and DAMDAM Tokyo, and we hold a 5.0 rating across 9 verified reviews on Clutch. We quote one fixed price after a discovery call, most stores launch in 6–10 weeks, and the team you meet is the team that builds.

If you are comparing agencies right now, book a free 30-minute call. We will answer all ten questions about your project.