A redesign is the most expensive way to improve conversion rate. Before you commit to one, work through this checklist. These are the fixes we look for first when a US brand asks us to audit their Shopify store, and most of them take days, not months.
01 — Speed
Speed and Mobile
- Test your product and collection pages on a real mid-range phone over cellular, not on office Wi-Fi.
- Remove apps you no longer use. Uninstalled apps often leave scripts behind in the theme.
- Compress and lazy-load images below the fold, and serve modern formats.
- Check Core Web Vitals in Search Console and fix the templates that fail.
- Make tap targets big enough and keep the add-to-cart button visible on mobile.
02 — Product Page
Product Pages
- Lead with the outcome the product delivers, not just its name.
- Show price, shipping cost and delivery time near the add-to-cart button.
- Use photos and short videos that answer real questions: size, texture, how it’s used.
- Put reviews, with photos, close to the buy button.
- Answer the top five objections in an FAQ on the page.
- Offer subscribe and save where it makes sense, with the savings shown clearly.
03 — Navigation
Navigation and Search
- Name menu items the way customers describe products, not internal names.
- Make search find products by benefit and misspelling, and track what people search for.
- Add filters on collections with more than a dozen products.
- Link best sellers and bundles from the homepage and the menu.
04 — Cart
Cart and Average Order Value
Bigger baskets are often easier to win than more orders. Our guide to bundles and average order value goes deeper.
- Show a free-shipping progress bar in the cart.
- Offer one relevant add-on or bundle in the cart, not five.
- Keep the cart drawer simple, with a clear checkout button.
- Test bundle and volume pricing on your best sellers.
05 — Checkout
Checkout and Trust
- Turn on accelerated checkouts such as Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay.
- Don’t surprise people with shipping costs or taxes at the last step.
- Show the returns policy and guarantee in plain words before checkout.
- Make contact options and a real business address easy to find.
- Send abandoned-checkout emails and texts with a clear reason to come back.
06 — Measure
Measure, Then Test
Fixes only count if you can see their effect. Our guide to A/B testing your website covers how to run tests properly.
- Track conversion rate, add-to-cart rate and revenue per visitor by device, not just overall.
- Change one important thing at a time and A/B test it when you have the traffic.
07 — Next Step
When a Redesign Is the Right Call
If you have worked through this list and the store still underperforms, or the theme makes these fixes slow and expensive, a rebuild will pay back faster than more patches. That is when we usually recommend a custom store.
Want us to run this checklist on your store? We are a New York-based Shopify Plus agency. book a free 30-minute call and we will walk through your biggest opportunities.